The weird 2011 demise of a beloved Philadelphia college trainer who was discovered with 20 stab wounds was but once more dominated a suicide — however her household’s lawyer blasted the newest report as “tripe.”
Within the newest report on the high-profile case launched Friday, the coroner’s workplace stated a brand new overview of the proof decided that Ellen Greenberg, 27, doubtless took her personal life on Jan. 26, 2011 in her condo, Folks Journal reported.
Greenberg was discovered with stab wounds throughout, together with the again of her head and her coronary heart.
“Whereas the distribution of accidents is admittedly uncommon, the very fact stays that Ellen could be able to inflicting these accidents herself,” Philadelphia’s Chief Medical Examiner Lindsay Simon wrote, the outlet stated.
Simon described Greenberg as a “younger girl affected by anxiousness.
“With all of this data thought of, it’s the opinion of the undersigned that the style of Ellen Greenberg’s demise is finest labeled as ‘suicide,’” Simon wrote on Friday. “All opinions state on this report are expressed with an inexpensive diploma of medical certainty.”
The ruling is the newest twist within the wild case, which has seen Greenberg’s heartbroken mother and father twice sue town and the health worker for allegedly botching the investigation.
In a scathing assertion to The Submit on Monday, Joseph Podraza, a accomplice with the legislation agency of Lamb McErlane, which represents Ellen Greenberg’s mother and father, referred to as the brand new ME report “tripe.”
“It contains false claims, just like the assertion {that a} stab wound in Ellen’s spinal column was made throughout post-mortem, a concept rejected by each credible knowledgeable, together with town’s personal neuropathologist,” he stated.
Podraza referred to as Simon’s overview “deeply flawed,” and stated it ignored unexplained bruises, lacking surveillance footage from the scene and a recreation that discovered Greenberg couldn’t trigger the injuries.
“Simon builds a flimsy case on distorted portrayals of Ellen’s psychological well being, propped up by cynical distortions of Ellen’s managed anxiousness, a situation extensively skilled day by day by over 40 million Individuals,” the lawyer stated. “Disgrace on you, Simon.”
Greenberg was discovered lifeless in her Philadelphia condo by her fiancé, Sam Goldberg, throughout a blizzard.
The post-mortem decided that she was riddled with bruises and suffered 20 stab wounds, together with to her neck, again, head and coronary heart — with a knife discovered protruding from her chest.
Goldberg has by no means been thought of a suspect.
Within the preliminary post-mortem report, then-assistant coroner Marlon Osbourne dominated Greenberg’s demise a murder.
However that modified weeks later, when Osbourne met with Philadelphia police and bizarrely modified his ruling to suicide, sparking the primary wave of controversy over the case.
In 2023, an appellate court docket referred to as the police investigation into the trainer’s demise “deeply flawed,” however upheld the ME’s suicide ruling within the case.
Osbourne later flipped once more, and in February referred to as it “one thing apart from suicide.“
The lifeless girl’s mother and father, Sandee and Josh Greenberg, questioned the suicide ruling and filed their lawsuits, in the meantime enlisting the providers of two forensics specialists to dispute the suicide ruling.
In February, the Greenbergs settled their claims in alternate for an undisclosed quantity of damages and an settlement by town that their daughter’s case would once more be reviewed, Folks stated.
