The scandalous trial of New Jersey tech boss, Paul Caneiro, who’s accused of slaughtering his brother and his brother’s household, will wrap up Thursday — as prosecutors blasted his “far-fetched” protection idea {that a} third brother framed him.
The protection legal professional for Caneiro, 59, instructed to jurors throughout closing arguments in Monmouth County court docket that started Wednesday that Paul and Keith’s different brother, Corey Caneiro, could have truly killed Keith, his spouse and their children on Nov. 20, 2018.
And if Paul was convicted of the alleged body job, then Corey, 52, would change into the only heir of Keith’s $3 million household belief, protection legal professional Monika Mastellone instructed the jury on the finish of the month-long trial.
However prosecutor Chris Decker instructed the panelists in his personal closing arguments — that started Wednesday afternoon and continued into Thursday morning — that “there was nothing there that made Corey Caneiro appear like a suspect.”
In actual fact, Corey didn’t even know he and Paul have been “contingent beneficiaries” — or those who stood to inherit if Keith, 50, and his entire household died.
Paul, who was put accountable for Keith’s belief arrange in 1999, would forfeit his inheritance if convicted of homicide, Decker argued.
“It’s a far-fetched argument that we should always have accused Corey Caneiro of homicide as a result of he stood to achieve $1.5 million that he didn’t even learn about,” the prosecutor instructed the jury Wednesday.
In the meantime, Paul stole from Keith “19 instances in 2018,” which Keith confronted Paul in regards to the night time earlier than he was discovered shot within the head exterior his burned-down residence along with his household slaughtered inside, Decker stated.
“Did you hear any proof that Corey Caneiro stole from his brother?” Decker stated.
Paul disabled the safety cameras at his residence in Ocean Township, N.J., proper earlier than setting his personal home on fireplace in a bid to make it seem like he was additionally being focused, prosecutors claimed.
“He must be the unluckiest man on the earth,” Decker stated. “Shut off his cameras. Get framed however then not be capable to show he bought framed as a result of he shut off his cameras.”
Throughout 4 hours of closings by Mastellone that concluded Wednesday, she claimed there was affordable doubt written everywhere in the case, with investigators allegedly failing to look into vital proof, failing to think about an alternate suspect, and usually falling prey to “tunnel imaginative and prescient” and “affirmation bias.”
Mastellone tried to dismantle what prosecutors say motivated Paul’s crimes — crushing cash issues, partially due to bankrolling holidays along with his a gal pal and paying for her new Audi sports activities automotive.
Paul was dwelling inside his means and although he took cash from his brother’s belief, he was within the technique of paying it again — similar to he at all times had, Mastellone argued.
She additionally claimed Paul was so near Keith and his household that he may by no means perform such callous killings.
Paul wiped his eyes with a material as Mastellone described his close-knit relationship with Keith’s household.
Paul allegedly went to Keith’s residence hours after Keith yelled at him, demanding solutions in regards to the lacking cash, in response to prosecutors.
He reduce the facility, turned off the generator and waited for Keith to come back exterior earlier than taking pictures him within the head 5 instances, prosecutors declare.
Paul then went inside, the place he shot and stabbed his sister-in-law, Jennifer, 45, after which stabbed his 11-year-old nephew, Jesse, and his 8-year-old niece, Sophia, prosecutors allege.
Paul lit a slow-burning fireplace on the residence and returned to his home and torched that one too — however ensured his personal spouse and daughters made it out alive, prosecutors argued.
He’s pleaded not responsible and has been in jail since his arrest.
Decker is anticipated to wrap up his closing arguments Thursday morning and jurors will seemingly start deliberating later Thursday.
